New preprint: does an AI's national origin change how persuasive it is?
A new preprint on arXiv, coauthored by faculty member Jonas R. Kunst and PhD member Yannic Hinrichs, finds that U.S. participants assimilated a chatbot’s arguments regardless of whether it was labeled American or Chinese—withholding social trust from a rival’s AI but still updating their attitudes toward it.
A preregistered experiment in which 403 U.S. adults held a three-round debate with a chatbot labeled as either American ("DiscoveryAI") or Chinese ("ZhengheAI")—though all participants actually conversed with the same model (GPT-4o) arguing against their initial position. Conversations produced substantial attitude change in every condition, and the nationality label affected neither attitude change nor expressed stance, concessions, counterarguing, or affect; its only reliable trace was lower pre-conversation social trust in the Chinese-labeled model. Users withhold social trust from a rival's AI yet still absorb its arguments, suggesting that origin labeling and transparency requirements offer weak protection against foreign influence operations run through conversational AI.